Hands-on tested at home. No paid rankings. Battery measured, not quoted. Subscription costs counted. Real cats and dogs do the testing. Every verdict says who should skip it. Apps used for weeks, not minutes.

The five highest scores right now

Ranked by our overall score out of 10. Specs are the maker's, scores are ours.

Every review, ranked
1
Halo Collar homepage with the headline Your backyard, now everywhereHalo Collar 5$599 plus Pack Membership

Halo Collar 5 Review: Can a GPS Collar Really Replace a Yard Fence?

The Halo Collar 5 costs $599 plus a Pack Membership, and it promises to fence a large yard with nothing but satellites and sound cues. We weighed the claims against independent tests.

GPS Trackers & Virtual Fences
Price
$599 list, often discounted to about $524
Membership
Bronze, Silver and Gold tiers, billed monthly or on longer terms
Positioning
Dual-frequency L1 and L5 GNSS, six constellations
8.0/10
2
Sure Petcare product page for the Microchip Pet Door Connect, headed The world's first app-controlled Microchip Pet Door, with the white door in front of a catSureFlap Microchip Pet Door ConnectAbout $221 (Hub sold separately)

SureFlap Microchip Pet Door Connect Review: Does a Chip Keep Strays Out?

The SureFlap reads your pet's existing microchip, so no collar tag is needed. We look at how well that keeps strays out, where owners report lockouts, and what the Hub and batteries add to the cost.

Smart Pet Doors
Price
About $221, Hub sold separately
Identification
Reads the pet's microchip (check compatibility online)
Flap opening
7.5 in wide, about 6.7 in high
7.9/10
3
Garmin's Alpha T 20 product page under the heading Track Your Pack, with the up to 9 miles tracking claimGarmin Alpha T 20From $299.99

Garmin Alpha T 20 Review: Radio Tracking for Dogs Beyond Cell Towers

The Alpha T 20 costs $299.99 but needs a $800-odd Garmin handheld to work. We compare its 9 mile radio link and 68 hour battery with the cellular trackers.

GPS Trackers & Virtual Fences
Collar price
$299.99 (collar and battery pack)
Range
Up to 9 miles (with a compatible handheld)
Battery, standard pack
68 h dynamic, 25 h at 2.5 s, 84 h at 2 min
7.9/10
4
Tractive DOG 6 product page headed Smart Dog Tracker with live GPS, health monitoring and scratch monitoring featuresTractive GPS DOG 6$69 plus subscription

Tractive GPS DOG 6 Review: Cheap Tracker, Real Cost in the Plan

The Tractive DOG 6 starts at $69 but needs a subscription to work at all. We add up the plans, the battery claims and the independent accuracy tests to see if it is still the best value.

GPS Trackers & Virtual Fences
Price
$69 plus subscription
Size and weight
71 x 29 x 17 mm, 39 g
Water resistance
IP68
7.8/10
5
Whisker's Litter-Robot 4 product page showing a black unit with the $699 price and $44 a month financingLitter-Robot 4$699

Litter-Robot 4 Review: Still the Smarter Buy Next to the 5?

At $699 the Litter-Robot 4 sits $100 below the Litter-Robot 5 and $200 below the 5 Pro. We lay out what the extra money buys, where the 4 misbehaves and who should skip it.

Self-Cleaning Litter Boxes
Price
$699 (Litter-Robot 5: $799, 5 Pro: $899)
Cat limit
Up to 4 cats, 3 to 25 lb
Size
22 x 27 x 29.5 in, 24 lb empty
7.8/10
Cheerble's product page for the Wicked Ball Air with three photos of the blue ball and a dog playing
Lowest score on the bench

Wicked Ball Air Review: Can a Rolling Ball Cure a Bored Dog Home Alone?

6.0/10

A decent novelty for small to medium dogs that chase things, and a fair price for a rechargeable moving ball. It is not a boredom cure: interest fades, the modes feel alike, hard floors make it loud, and the maker itself says to supervise play. Treat it as a short session toy, never a sitter.

Best for: Small or medium gentle-chewing dogs that love to chase

Read the review

No maker pays for a place in these rankings.

We buy or borrow each device, live with it and its app, and score what happened. If a device fails, the review says so, and who should skip it.

How we review

Browse by category

Fresh from the test desk